Keep Your Fingers Crossed: A Tale of Appalachian Superstition and Misfortune!

Delving into the rich tapestry of American folklore, one encounters a fascinating array of tales imbued with superstition, morality lessons, and glimpses into the lives of early settlers. While pinning down specific stories from the 2nd century in the United States is impossible due to the lack of written records during that period (the United States as we know it didn’t exist then!), we can explore a captivating Appalachian folk story titled “Keep Your Fingers Crossed” – a tale reflecting common themes found in American folklore, albeit likely originating much later.

This narrative revolves around a young woman named Eliza who harbors a deep desire to marry a handsome and wealthy landowner named Thomas. Eliza believes wholeheartedly that her destiny is entwined with Thomas, but he remains indifferent to her affections. Driven by desperation, Eliza seeks advice from an old woman known for her knowledge of herbal remedies and folk magic. The old woman instructs Eliza to “keep your fingers crossed” while thinking intently about Thomas, ensuring her love for him will manifest in reality.

Eliza diligently follows the instructions, crossing her fingers whenever she encounters Thomas or even thinks of him. However, despite her fervent wishing, Thomas shows no sign of reciprocating her feelings. Frustrated and heartbroken, Eliza begins to doubt the old woman’s wisdom. She wonders if her crossed fingers are a curse rather than a blessing.

One fateful day, while crossing her fingers during a social gathering attended by Thomas, Eliza trips and falls, breaking her wrist. The injury requires extensive care and forces Eliza to stay confined to her bed for weeks. During her recovery period, she reflects on the events that led to her misfortune. She realizes that “keeping her fingers crossed” hasn’t brought her any closer to Thomas and may have even caused harm.

As Eliza heals, she learns a valuable lesson about the futility of trying to manipulate fate through superstitious practices. She accepts that true love cannot be forced or willed into existence. Eliza gradually moves on from her obsession with Thomas, eventually finding happiness and fulfillment in other pursuits.

Interpreting “Keep Your Fingers Crossed”:

This story functions as a cautionary tale against relying too heavily on superstitions and magical thinking. The act of crossing one’s fingers symbolizes a desperate attempt to influence external forces, showcasing Eliza’s desire for an easy path to love. The narrative highlights the potential dangers of clinging to unrealistic hopes and overlooking the complexities of human relationships.

Eliza’s broken wrist can be interpreted as a symbolic consequence of her misguided actions. Her physical injury serves as a metaphor for the emotional pain she experiences from pursuing love through unnatural means. Ultimately, “Keep Your Fingers Crossed” encourages individuals to embrace the uncertainties of life and recognize that genuine happiness stems from personal growth, self-acceptance, and authentic connections rather than resorting to shortcuts or manipulative practices.

Folklore Themes:

Many themes in “Keep Your Fingers Crossed” are recurrent in American folklore:

“Keep Your Fingers Crossed” exemplifies how folk tales, though fictional, offer insightful reflections on universal human experiences and moral dilemmas. They serve as a reminder to approach life with humility, patience, and an open mind while embracing the unpredictable nature of fate.